### Phantom Equity Plans: Structure and Legal Considerations in Malaysia

Phantom equity plans (PEPs) are increasingly popular in Malaysia as companies seek innovative ways to incentivize employees without the need to offer actual ownership stakes. Phantom equity is a contractual agreement that provides employees with a benefit tied to the company’s valuation without transferring actual equity. Here, we explore the basics of phantom equity, its implementation in Malaysia, and key legal considerations to ensure regulatory compliance.

---

#### 1. **What is Phantom Equity?**

Phantom equity, also known as shadow stock, mirrors the value of actual company stock, allowing employees to benefit from the company's financial success without owning shares. Employees do not receive dividends or voting rights but may be granted cash bonuses equivalent to the appreciation of the company’s share value. This aligns employees' interests with shareholders and incentivizes them to contribute to the company's growth.

#### 2. **How Phantom Equity Plans Work**

Phantom equity plans are typically structured in the following manner:

1. **Allocation of Units:** Employees receive phantom units (or phantom shares) that are linked to the company's stock price or valuation.

2. **Vesting Periods:** Similar to traditional stock options, phantom equity usually includes a vesting schedule (e.g., 3–5 years) to encourage employee retention.

3. **Payout on Liquidity Events:** Employees receive payouts based on an appreciation in share value, typically at specific events such as mergers, acquisitions, IPOs, or other liquidity events.

#### 3. **Advantages of Phantom Equity Plans**

   - **No Dilution:** Since no shares are issued, the founders' ownership stake is unaffected.

   - **Flexibility:** Phantom equity provides flexibility in structuring rewards based on performance without altering the company’s cap table.

   - **Alignment with Company Goals:** This can motivate employees to work toward a common objective, improving productivity and retention.

### Legal and Regulatory Considerations in Malaysia

When structuring phantom equity plans, Malaysian companies must consider legal and regulatory requirements. Here are some key considerations:

#### 1. **Employment Law Compliance**

Malaysian employment law, under the Employment Act 1955, does not specifically regulate phantom equity plans. However, companies must ensure that PEPs comply with general employment law provisions, particularly concerning employee entitlements, contract terms, and termination procedures. 

When drafting the PEP agreement, it is essential to clarify that it is a contractual benefit and not an ownership stake. This prevents ambiguity and reinforces the notion that employees hold no equity and have no shareholder rights.

#### 2. **Tax Implications**

Phantom equity is taxed differently from traditional equity-based compensation. In Malaysia, income tax is imposed on employees upon realization (i.e., when they receive cash payouts). Companies should work closely with tax advisors to determine how payouts are classified under Malaysian tax law, generally as additional employment income, and ensure compliance with filing requirements.

For employers, phantom equity payouts are often tax-deductible, providing a cost-effective way to incentivize employees without the tax complexity that traditional stock options entail.

#### 3. **Contractual Obligations and Enforceability**

A well-drafted phantom equity agreement is crucial to mitigate potential disputes and ensure enforceability under Malaysian contract law. The agreement should clearly define:

   - **Terms of Vesting:** Outline specific vesting milestones and conditions.

   - **Conditions for Payouts:** Detail the events that trigger payouts, such as liquidity events.

   - **Valuation Methodology:** Specify how the company's value will be determined for calculating payouts.

   - **Termination Clauses:** Define circumstances under which the phantom equity plan is forfeited or modified.

Malaysian companies should consider obtaining legal counsel to draft agreements that fully align with contract law principles under the Contracts Act 1950.

#### 4. **Corporate Governance and Disclosure Obligations**

Companies offering phantom equity plans may be required to disclose such arrangements to shareholders, particularly if they are publicly listed. While privately held companies may not have the same obligations, transparency with shareholders is essential for maintaining trust.

For publicly listed entities, the Companies Act 2016 and regulations under Bursa Malaysia may require disclosure of significant compensation schemes, including phantom equity plans, especially if these impact the company’s finances or create potential liabilities.

#### 5. **Securities Law and Regulatory Approval**

Unlike actual stock options or equity grants, phantom equity does not fall under securities law in Malaysia because no shares are issued. Consequently, companies do not need approval from the Securities Commission Malaysia (SC) to implement phantom equity. However, companies should ensure that employees fully understand that phantom shares do not confer shareholder status or rights, reducing the risk of future misunderstandings.

---

### Steps for Implementing a Phantom Equity Plan in Malaysia

To successfully implement a phantom equity plan in Malaysia, consider the following steps:

1. **Consult Legal and Tax Advisors:** Professional guidance helps ensure that the plan complies with Malaysian law and minimizes tax liabilities for both employees and the company.

2. **Draft a Detailed Agreement:** Use clear language in the PEP agreement, outlining terms, conditions, and vesting schedules.

3. **Employee Communication and Education:** Ensure employees understand the nature of phantom equity, particularly its distinction from actual ownership.

4. **Establish a Transparent Valuation Mechanism:** Regular valuation by an independent party is advisable for accurate payouts and helps avoid disputes.

---

### Conclusion

Phantom equity plans are an attractive solution for Malaysian companies seeking to retain talent without diluting ownership. By structuring the plan with a solid understanding of legal considerations—particularly in employment law, taxation, contract law, and corporate governance—companies can create an effective incentive that aligns employee interests with company growth. For a company looking to leverage this tool effectively, partnering with experienced legal and tax advisors is crucial to design a compliant and successful phantom equity plan.